Compare Medicare Advantage and Medigap, with help from AI

4 min readHealth

AI won't pick a plan for you, but it can lay the choices side by side in plain words and help you ask the right questions.

Every fall, people on Medicare get to look at their coverage again. Medicare open enrollment runs from Oct 15 to Dec 7. The big choice is between two paths: Medicare Advantage, or Original Medicare with a Medigap policy and a Part D drug plan. The words alone can make your head spin. An AI chat app like ChatGPT, Gemini or Claude can explain them in plain words and help you get ready to compare real plans.

Step 1: Get the words straight

Example: "Explain in plain words, like I'm new to this: Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage, Medigap and Part D. For each one, tell me in two sentences what it covers and how it works with the others."

Ask it to make a short glossary you can print, with words like premium, deductible, copay and network.

Step 2: Tell AI what matters to you

AI can't see your plan or your health, so you tell it what matters.

Example: "I'm 71. I see a heart doctor twice a year, take 4 prescriptions, and spend winters in another state. Make a side-by-side table of what to check under Medicare Advantage vs Original Medicare with Medigap and Part D: doctors, travel, drugs and yearly costs. Don't guess prices. Just tell me what to look up."

Don't type your Medicare number, Social Security number or date of birth into an AI chat. You don't need them for this.

Step 3: Check your drugs and doctors

Make a list of your medicines with the dose, and your doctors' names.

Example: "Turn this list into a checklist I can use with the Medicare Plan Finder: for each plan, does it cover each drug, and are my doctors in its network?"

Then look the plans up yourself on Medicare.gov or call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227; TTY 1-877-486-2048).

Step 4: Questions for a free counselor

Every state has a free, unbiased Medicare counseling program called SHIP (State Health Insurance Assistance Program). Find yours at shiphelp.org or call 1-877-839-2675.

Example: "Write 8 short questions I can ask a SHIP counselor about switching between Medicare Advantage and Original Medicare, including what happens if I want to switch back later."

Bring your checklist from Step 3. The counselor can look at real plans in your area with you.

Things to know

• AI can be out of date or wrong about plans, prices and rules. Check every detail on Medicare.gov, with the plan, or with a SHIP counselor before you decide.
• If you leave Original Medicare for an Advantage plan and later want to come back, a Medigap policy may ask health questions, cost more or turn you down. Some people have a one-time right to switch back within the first 12 months, and some states give extra protections. Ask a SHIP counselor before you switch.
• Watch for calls or mail that pressure you to switch today. Medicare will never call you to sell you anything. If a caller says they're from Medicare, hang up and call 1-800-MEDICARE yourself.

Also read: Using AI to get ready for Medicare Open Enrollment

Also read: Use AI to understand health insurance open enrollment

Also read: Use AI to get ready for a doctor visit

Also read: How to use AI to check if a message is a scam